(612) 236-4105

We Shop. You Save.

We compare rates with top insurance providers so you don't have to.

Request A Quote

Bluejay Insurance Agency, Inc.

AAA Insurance
American Strategic Insurance
Encompass Insurance
Safeco Insurance
State Auto
West Bend Mutual Insurance
The Hartford
American Modern Insurance Group
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate
Berkshire Hathaway Guard
EMC Insurance
Foremost Insurance Group
Nationwide Insurance
Integrity Insurance
Selective Insurance
Universal Property and Casualty

Independent Insurance Agency in Minneapolis, MN

Custom Insurance to Protect your Family or Business

Our number one priority is protecting you and your family. That means crafting custom insurance plans designed around your risk exposure and using insurance companies with a proven track record of stepping up when it comes time for a claim.

Partnered With 20 Top Insurance Companies

Getting quotes is simple & efficient because we do all the work for you. BlueJay Insurance Agency will compare rates with top providers and tailor a plan specific to your needs and wants.


  • 5 star review  Jay is extremely thorough and works hard to find you the best coverage at the best value on an individualized basis. He always takes the time to call and walk you through the details of your coverage and explain the details in plain English so you know exactly what you are getting and fully understand your plan. My fiance and I have really appreciated Jay's responsiveness and reliable follow-through. I highly recommend BlueJay Insurance to anyone looking to improve their service experience.

    thumb Dan Fleissner

    5 star review  Jay has been extremely helpful with our business insurance needs. He is knowledgeable and always recommends the right coverage for our needs. Highly recommended!

    thumb EH HUG

    5 star review  I reached out online for a quote and was contacted within minutes. Tanner was incredibly patient, professional, and helpful. He took the time to explain the details of all of my policies. I'm very glad I found such a great local company.

    thumb Sydney Schack-Farnell
  • 5 star review  Excellent service and attention to detail. Maintains great contact and is always responsive when you need help.

    thumb Wael Salem

    5 star review  Jay has been a pleasure to work with! He is profession, attentive, and genuine with his customers. He is also very knowledgeable in the space and took the time to walk me through the fine details of my insurance policy so I could better understand.

    thumb Nich Lingl

    5 star review  I worked with Tanner at BlueJay Insurance and he was great to work with! Very responsive, knowledgeable and great rates! I’d recommend Tanner and BlueJay to anyone looking for P&C insurance!

    thumb Garrett Emond
  • 5 star review  I highly recommend BlueJay Insurance Agency. Jay was extremely professional, timely in his responses and a pleasure to work with. He exceeded my expectations and worked quickly to ensure all of my insurance needs were met.

    thumb Kelsea Kern

    5 star review  Jay's awesome - quick to respond, down to earth, and works hard to find the best option for whatever your situation is.

    thumb Katrina R.

    5 star review  When working with BlueJay Insurance Agency what I appreciate is knowing they are working in my best interest to find a good value for me. Not too much insurance, not too little. Regardless of what the catchy commercials say, not all insurance carriers are great to work with when you need them most. The BlueJay team understands this! I am confident in recommending them as they have been a great addition to my team and I would expect you'll experience the same.

    thumb Mitch Seiffert

Contact Us


Send A Note
1229 Tyler St NE – Suite 292 Minneapolis

Office Hours: 9am-5pm Mon-Fri