(612) 236-4105

We Shop. You Save.

We compare rates with top insurance providers so you don't have to.

Request A Quote

Bluejay Insurance Agency

AAA - The Auto Club Group - Independent Insurance Agent
American Strategic Insurance
Encompass Insurance
Safeco Insurance
State Auto
West Bend Mutual Insurance
Pure Insurance
The Hartford
American Modern Insurance Group
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate
Berkshire Hathaway Guard
EMC Insurance
Foremost Insurance Group
Nationwide Insurance
Integrity Insurance
Selective Insurance
Universal Property and Casualty

Independent Insurance Agency in Minneapolis, MN

Custom Insurance to Protect your Family or Business

Our number one priority is protecting you and your family. That means crafting custom insurance plans designed around your risk exposure and using insurance companies with a proven track record of stepping up when it comes time for a claim.

Partnered With 20 Top Insurance Companies

Getting quotes is simple & efficient because we do all the work for you. BlueJay Insurance Agency will compare rates with top providers and tailor a plan specific to your needs and wants.


  • We depend on Jay to help us choose the right insurance for our condominium and individual owners, and he has never let us down! We appreciate his prompt responses and his thorough answers to our questions. We depend on Jay and the BlueJay Insurance Agency and we're convinced they're the very best!

    Evoynel Olson Avatar Evoynel Olson
    June 7, 2023

    Jay was very helpful getting my new homeowners & auto insurance policies arranged. He was very thorough, and I was pleasantly surprised at the money I was able to save. He made the process quick & easy. Customer service after has also been great. Very quick to respond to any questions. Would highly recommend!

    Katie Florin Avatar Katie Florin
    May 25, 2023

    Can not possibly say more about the fantastic service I received from Jay Schleicher and BlueJay Insurance. We needed something on very short notice, and Jay did a fantastic job getting everything we needed done, efficiently and economically. We'll definitely be checking back with Jay for our future insurance needs.

    Tom Hultquist Avatar Tom Hultquist
    May 1, 2023
  • Superb customer service over several years and always provides thorough and honest advice. I would recommend Blue Jay Insurance to all my friends and family.

    Drew Savage Avatar Drew Savage
    February 14, 2023

    I recently had my first car accident and had to actually use my car insurance. I had a lot going on when I signed up for my policy, so Jay just picked out the best options for me and handled everything. Now, I am SO GLAD I let him choose everything because he thought of it all. I have all the coverages I probably wouldn’t have gotten myself, because Jay knew what was best and took care of it for me. It has made this stressful event so much smoother and I’ll let Jay pick out my insurance forever. He also called to check on me and make sure I was okay. So kind, so thoughtful, so professional. Can’t recommend him enough.

    Jenna Henry Avatar Jenna Henry
    December 5, 2022

    Tanner worked with us to find competitive insurance. He promptly communicated with us, took the time to compare and explain policy differences, and ultimately got us the coverage we needed at a great price!

    Hillary Myers Avatar Hillary Myers
    October 14, 2022
  • We just purchased our first home and it was my first time purchasing property insurance. Jay Schleicher came recommended to me, so I called BlueJay out of the blue and they had me ready to go with a policy in an hour. During that time, Jay described all of the different options, why prices were higher or lower across insurers, and how all of the coverage work. Way faster than I would have expected. Very response and helpful - would definitely recommend.

    Benjamin Slutsker Avatar Benjamin Slutsker
    August 7, 2022

    I love this agency! I worked with Austin and he was very efficient and patient with how complex my situation was! I worked quickly and was very friendly. I would suggest this agency to anyone, truly. He found the perfect insurance agency for the best rate for me and even got it lower than my old insurance without me asking. Amazing company :D

    Ajani Hale Avatar Ajani Hale
    July 22, 2022

    Austin at Bluejay was very helpful in assisting me with finding a renter's insurance policy. He was very available and was even able to talk on the phone after hours. I now have a good policy at a good price, just a few days after I first reached out :)

    B Charlot Avatar B Charlot
    July 15, 2022

Contact Us


Send A Note

1229 Tyler St NE – Suite 292 Minneapolis

Office Hours: 9am-5pm Mon-Fri

Skip to content