(612) 236-4105

We Shop. You Save.

We compare rates with top insurance providers so you don't have to.

Request A Quote

Bluejay Insurance Agency, Inc.

AAA Insurance
American Strategic Insurance
Encompass Insurance
Safeco Insurance
State Auto
West Bend Mutual Insurance
The Hartford
American Modern Insurance Group
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate
Berkshire Hathaway Guard
EMC Insurance
Foremost Insurance Group
Nationwide Insurance
Integrity Insurance
Selective Insurance
Universal Property and Casualty

Independent Insurance Agency in Minneapolis, MN

Custom Insurance to Protect your Family or Business

Our number one priority is protecting you and your family. That means crafting custom insurance plans designed around your risk exposure and using insurance companies with a proven track record of stepping up when it comes time for a claim.

Partnered With 20 Top Insurance Companies

Getting quotes is simple & efficient because we do all the work for you. BlueJay Insurance Agency will compare rates with top providers and tailor a plan specific to your needs and wants.


  • 5 star review  Jay was excellent to work with in helping us transition to a different insurance company that had better rates and with more coverage for both our auto and home policies! He took time to walk through all of the details of our coverages also. Look forward to working with BlueJay for years to come!

    thumb Lisa Ostrander
    May 10, 2022

    5 star review  Best Insurance Company I have ever dealt with. So far I have only worked with Austin but he is amazing and fast at responding and helping with whatever you may need. Will for sure be using them for the for seeable future for any insurance needs I have. Thank you to the friends at BlueJay Insurance for all the help and GREAT customer service. HIGHLY recommend.

    thumb Erin Mathena
    April 15, 2022

    5 star review  Jay at BlueJay Insurance assisted us with setting up Vehicle and Renters Insurance. He was informative, timely, and patient with all of our questions. We've been able to interact with him a few times since the initial meeting and would highly recommend him and the company to anyone in the market for a new insurance provider.

    thumb brad mills
    March 23, 2022
  • 5 star review  My experience with blue jay insurance has been quite Pleasant the person I work with is Tanner he has found me the best deals possible and has been very quick to get back with me I recommend blue Jay insurance to anyone who starting a business are for your Auto

    thumb Todd Johnson
    March 19, 2022

    5 star review  This is the first insurance company that I’ve had that makes me feel like I’m dealing with a friend and that I can trust has my best interest in mind. I no longer feel like I’m dealing with a company but a friend. BlueJay Insurance found me an affordable policy when no others could and for years after have always done what’s best for me. It’s nice to know you have found an insurance company for life!

    thumb Brentt Wessman
    March 17, 2022

    5 star review  Over my lifetime I've worked with different insurance agencies and now moving around often due to being in the military I found BlueJay Insurance Agency. The location is close to home, and the staff are friendly and helpful. Tanner from BlueJay has been extremely helpful and patient whenever I have questions and responds promptly when I need a new quote or new information. Needless to say they have my loyalty and respect as a client. I'm always thankful to know they got my back.

    thumb Smitywerbenjagerman Jeson
    March 17, 2022
  • 5 star review  Jay and the BlueJay team were very helpful, invested the time to listen to our insurance needs, and tailored an insurance package for our home, auto, and business. Very competitive rates with a much improved customer service level than my previous insurance provider.

    thumb Joe Heser
    March 16, 2022

    5 star review  I know NOTHING about insurance. Literally nothing. As a first time home buyer, Jay let me be myself, ask allll of the confusing questions, and educated me with patience. He got me an indescribably incredible rate and he always has my best interest in mind. 11/10 would recommend working with Jay and his team!

    thumb Grace Fjellanger
    January 25, 2022

    5 star review  Jay at BlueJay Insurance was prompt in my initial inquiry, professional, and friendly. He also found me better insurance with more coverage that saves me money each year. Thanks, Jay and Team! I would absolutely recommend them!

    thumb Katie Stone
    November 13, 2021

Contact Us


Send A Note
1229 Tyler St NE – Suite 292 Minneapolis

Office Hours: 9am-5pm Mon-Fri

Skip to content