We Shop. You Save.

We compare rates with top insurance providers so you don't have to.

Request A Quote

Bluejay Insurance Agency, Inc.

AAA Insurance
American Strategic Insurance
Encompass Insurance
Safeco Insurance
State Auto
West Bend Mutual Insurance
The Hartford
American Modern Insurance Group
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate
Berkshire Hathaway Guard
EMC Insurance
Foremost Insurance Group
Nationwide Insurance
Integrity Insurance
Selective Insurance
Universal Property and Casualty

Independent Insurance Agency in Minneapolis, MN

Custom Insurance to Protect your Family or Business

Our number one priority is protecting you and your family. That means crafting custom insurance plans designed around your risk exposure and using insurance companies with a proven track record of stepping up when it comes time for a claim.

Partnered With 20 Top Insurance Companies

Getting quotes is simple & efficient because we do all the work for you. BlueJay Insurance Agency will compare rates with top providers and tailor a plan specific to your needs and wants.


  • review rating 5  When working with BlueJay Insurance Agency what I appreciate is knowing they are working in my best interest to find a good value for me. Not too much insurance, not too little. Regardless of what the catchy commercials say, not all insurance carriers are great to work with when you need them most. The BlueJay team understands this! I am confident in recommending them as they have been a great addition to my team and I would expect you'll experience the same.

    thumb Mitch Seiffert

    review rating 5  Jay is extremely professional, proficient and a great guy. He was able to find the best rates that met all my needs. If you’re looking for someone that has integrity and will work hard for you...look no further. I will definitely refer him to friends and family.

    thumb Chris Doering

    review rating 5  I’ll keep it simple for you. Jay has been our insurance agent for the last 3 years. We recently decided to start a business. We reached out to Jay, everything was done before we knew it! Very professional and insanely responsive! It’s nice knowing you have someone in your corner that has the knowledge and experience and will get the job done in a timely manner. Jared ain’t got nothing on Jay!

    thumb Ron Haynes
  • review rating 5  Jay provided us great service during the process of buying a home and switching all of our auto and home insurance to a new plan that works great for us. He was very thorough and informative and helped us to make the right decision.

    thumb Nick Walby

    review rating 5  I think I call Jay 4-6 times a year! He’s always super responsive and helps us out whether it’s for advice, making changes to policies or adding new policies and products into the mix. He knows our family and our needs- I have zero need to shop around anymore. Highly recommend!

    thumb Jamie Simpson

    review rating 5  Very grateful for Jay! I emailed him on a weekend needing some emergency information about my policies and he called me back immediately and dealt with the issue swiftly. Would highly recommend.

    thumb Christine Delp
  • review rating 5  Jay is solid. I had no affiliation with him before finding him online. I have rental property including two units that I rent as short-term rentals through Airbnb and Jay helped me find policies that were specific to my needs. We went through each policy line by line so I could get educated and make sure I had the right amount of coverage. He is approachable, tech savvy, knows insurance policy well and meets you where you're at with your current understanding of the insurance space. We also ended up saving a small amount of money with exponentially better coverage. Highly recommend reaching out to him if you're trying to get insurance off your plate and managed by someone you can trust.

    thumb Micah Perzichilli

    review rating 5  Jay is an amazing asset to our company in helping us with all our insurance needs. He's friendly, knowledgeable and fast! He makes it easier for us to run our business knowing that were are completely covered and protected by insurance.

    thumb Archi Pix

    review rating 5  When I was refinancing my house, my loan officer noticed I was paying a lot for homeowners insurance and referred me to Jay. He got back to me very quickly and within just a few days, I had new home, auto and umbrella policies in place with better coverage at a cheaper cost. Jay was a pleasure to work with. He responded quickly to me and answered all my questions. It's reassuring to know I'm properly insured and at the best price.

    thumb Kirsten Partenheimer

Contact Us


Send A Note
1229 Tyler St NE – Suite 292 Minneapolis

Office Hours: 9am-5pm Mon-Fri